Don't Set Goals—Create Systems

Cartoonists are an interesting lot: they have a job that many would see as being unproductive or even pointless, but since when did being incisive become unproductive?

Bill Watterson’s insights on life as expressed through Calvin and Hobbes have entertained and helped millions. If you haven’t seen this bit of tribute art, where a fan has drawn artwork to accompany the text of a speech by Bill then I highly recommend you take a look now. If you’re working from home and you’re the kind of person who wants to put family first then you may find its message particularly comforting.

When it comes to business we have Scott Adams, creator of Dilbert. The cartoon itself will make you chuckle but Adams also shares many insights from his long and varied career in his writings. In this article for the Wall Street Journal he makes two strong recommendations:

  1. Don’t set goals, create systems instead.
  2. Do not follow your passion.
Both of these ideas resonated strongly with me: on creating systems instead of setting goals I created Q2 which is my system for getting the important things in life done without setting rigid goals. Adams urges us to stop setting rigid goals such as “lose 10 pounds” for two key reasons:
  1. As soon as you have set the goal, you’re instantly in a state of failure, as naturally you’ve made no progress towards the goal yet.
  2. Once you lose those 10 pounds, then what? You have just lost your purpose; you could set yourself another goal but now moments after achieving your goal you’ve plunged yourself right back into a state of failure, again at 0% progress towards this new goal.
To this I would add that any lapses in progress can completely kill your enthusiasm and energy to work towards this goal. Say if you lose 8 pounds and you’re feeling great but then you attend a friend’s wedding, you enjoy the celebrations with everyone but then discover that you’ve just gained back 5 pounds, you’ll naturally feel like more of a failure and may just abandon the goal as hopeless.

This could also happen at a larger scale, say with a business venture. At the first major setback you may be so disheartened that you either quit straight away or otherwise lose your momentum and the venture fizzles out.

One way to get around this is to build systems that move you in the right direction. Setbacks are less important now as you aren’t fixated on a particular inflexible goal but rather a direction: stray away from that path and all you need to succeed today is to nudge yourself back towards that path. Keep doing that consistently and not only are you far more likely to succeed in your endeavour but you’re going to be generating a lot less negativity when you hit the inevitable setbacks that life will throw your way.

System may be slightly too big a word though; what we are looking for is just a bit more structure in our lives and some routines that help us through the week and keep us on the right track. Such systems/routines could be as simple as:

Admittedly the line can be blurry between what is a goal and what is a system: writing 1,000 words a day is basically a goal, but the structure you set up for yourself (writing first thing after breakfast) is what helps you get it done, and I would be tempted to drop the word count target and instead just focus on “turning up for work”: if you sit down after breakfast and start writing, and keep doing that consistently, then some days you will write much more than 1,000 words, others less, it doesn’t matter as you’re headed in the right direction.

Goals also bring more guilt into your life. This may be perfectly manageable if your only goal is to get in shape, but you probably have goals in your working life, regarding your family, your hobbies… keeping on top of all of these all the time is a near-impossibility, and focussing on one naturally de-emphasises the others to the point that you start to forget that you even made the commitment to yourself in the first place which causes further remorse.

One solution to this is to build one habit at a time, at a rate of no more than one a month. This month you’ll go running every morning until it’s more natural for you to go running than to not. Next month you’ll get into writing every day, the following month it will be something else.

The solution I prefer is to track when I give time to these important things in my life and use a system to see at a glance which parts I’ve been neglecting, and perhaps which activities I am over-committing on, to the detriment of other dimensions of life. No one wants to live like a robot, lapsing is inevitable and shouldn’t be a cause of guilt. Rather, you just pick one of these activities and spend some time on it. Such systems shouldn’t be telling you what to do each day, they should just be supporting you, making it easy to make each day productive without the guilt trip that you get as your calendar is spamming you with notifications and your ‘due’ todo list is an ever-growing mountain of things you should apparently be doing but aren’t.

If you like the idea of a general system which is designed to be low-guilt yet high impact then I’d like you to try Q2 and let me know what you think, and how you get on with it.

And if you have some systems that you’ve built into your life that help you be more effective, or simply spend more time on what’s important, then I’d love to hear about them.

Did you find this post useful? If you would like help with anything then you can contact me any time via Twitter.

Also if this kind of work interests you, my employer Mystery Applicant is hiring.